cover-art

Review by Mike published

Dream Theater

The Astonishing 2016

9 Prog Metal details

The key to liking this album is to understand that it is a musical. I like it a lot, some weaker tracks in over 2 hours of music not withstanding. I also think that in hindsight (2023), looking back on all the Mangini-era DT albums, this is the only one that is as creative in the pre-Mangini sense (think Scenes or 6 Degrees). It all flows nicely, the songwriting is REALLY inspired, and the occasional cheesy bit fits in nicely as well, as long as, like I said in the beginning, you appreciate this being a musical.

Tracks

8
8
9

Channeling Rush ... great way to kick off the story after the overture.

8
4. The Answer 1:52
7
9
9
9
9
9
10. Three Days 3:44
8
8
8
7
14. Ravenskill 6:01
8
15. Chosen 4:32
9
7
9
18. The X Aspect 4:13
9
8
9
9
8
23. Heaven's Cove 4:19
9
24. Begin Again 3:54
9
9
8
9
10
29. Losing Faythe 4:13

Tragic! However, that last cry at the end is hilarious.

9
8
7
32. Our New World 4:12
8
33. Power Down 1:25
9
34. Astonishing 5:51